The 50/30/20 rule: Is it realistic in a cost of living crisis?

The cost of living crisis has highlighted the importance of budgeting and financial planning. Here, we talk to two financial experts about the ‘50/30/20’ budgeting rule. Many will find that it’s not a realistic approach, given the cost of living squeeze, so we also look at some alternative budgeting methods.

What is the 50/30/20 rule?

“A 50/30/20 budget is a simple way of making a plan for your income and allocating your spend,” says financial coach Selina Flavius. “There are clear and distinctive categories - 50% for needs, 30% for wants and 20% to put aside as savings.”

For example, if £1,500 comes into your account each month, £750 would go towards your ‘needs’ - rent, council tax, energy bill, food and transport to and from work. This would leave you with £450 to spend on what you want and £300 to pay down credit card debt, or set aside for an emergency fund, in case something expensive breaks and you urgently need to fix it. Money for trips away or birthday presents for friends can come either from your ‘wants’ money or savings – it’s up to you.

“Some people find that it’s not possible to get all essentials into the 50% bracket, especially if they’re living in a central city,” says Selina. The increased cost of energy and groceries may also mean that essentials come to considerably more than 50% and that saving 20% simply isn’t possible.

Essentials versus non-essentials

To explore the 50/30/20 method, you’ll need to look at what you usually spend and decide what’s essential and what’s non-essential. You may want to note down various expenses in a spreadsheet or document so that you can categorise them into ‘needs’, ‘wants’ and savings.

“What do you need to live in your home, be fed, watered and clothed and feel financially secure? What could you live without? What couldn’t you live without?” asks financial planner and coach Catherine Morgan.

Once you understand how much you spend on your ‘needs’ and ‘wants’, you’ll have a better idea of whether the 50/30/20 split could work for you or if you need to adjust it or try a different method.

Alternative budgeting methods

The digital envelope method

If you’re looking for a budgeting method with no set percentages and more categories than ‘needs’, ‘wants’ and savings, you could try the envelope method.

“It comes from when people were paid cash-in-hand and would separate money out into different envelopes,” says Selina. “And it can work digitally if you have a bank like Starling with Spaces.”

Spaces is the feature in the Starling app that enables you to set money aside for particular purposes. For example: you could create different Spaces for your rent, utility bills, insurance, food, transport, and top up each Space with the amount you need to spend that month. You could then set up direct debits with the Bills Manager feature to pay bills directly from a Space.

You could also have Spaces for celebrations, coffee or takeaways – all of which are Spending categories available in the Starling app.

“I love Starling Spaces,” says Catherine. “You can bring everything to life with photographs and names.”

Budgeting with a spreadsheet

If you don’t have a bank with digital saving Spaces and don’t want to use physical cash or envelopes, you could outline your own categories and spending targets in a spreadsheet.

There are a number of apps, such as Emma or Money Dashboard, that can digitise this process and make it easier to check in on your budget.

Zero-based budgeting

If you allocate 100% of your income to various categories so that you have a balance of zero at the end of each month, you’ll be doing what’s known as zero-based budgeting. “You give every pound a purpose,” says Catherine. You might want to use one category for savings and another as a buffer to cover unexpected expenses.

Ultimately, there’s no one-size-fits-all approach when it comes to budgeting. It all depends on your income, fixed costs and financial goals.

To get started with budgeting, you may want to try our Budget Planner tool. It crunches the numbers for you so that you can set realistic targets within your budget – no matter which method you choose.